Nine of these films are set at Thanksgiving, and six are the big-family, long-table movies that belong next to them for the rest of the month. They count down from the family-dinner picks to the best Thanksgiving movie ever made, so you can work through the list from the first week of November to the night before the turkey.
Thanksgiving has a surprisingly small shelf of films set on the actual holiday. Christmas has hundreds; Thanksgiving has a few dozen, and the good ones are mostly about the same thing: getting home, and then surviving the people you find there.
So this list is honest about what it is. Numbers 9 to 1 all take place at Thanksgiving. Numbers 15 to 10 do not, and each entry says so, but they are the films people reach for in November anyway, because they are about a family around a table, and that is what the month is really about.
Every great Thanksgiving movie is a travel movie or a dinner movie. The best ones are both.
For the rest of November: the family-table films
None of these six is set on Thanksgiving. They are here because they are about the same feeling: a crowded house, too much food, and an argument that has been waiting years to happen.
15The Cookout
A $30 million contract, one backyard, and every relative who heard about it.
A rookie signs a $30 million deal with his hometown New Jersey Nets and throws a barbecue at his new house to keep things real, which fails the moment family, old friends, agents and sponsors share a lawn. Queen Latifah produced it, shares the story credit and turns up as a security guard, alongside Jenifer Lewis, Tim Meadows and Danny Glover.
It is a summer cookout, not Thanksgiving, and it is the loosest film here. Watch it when the house is full and nobody wants anything heavier than a plate of ribs.
14The Family That Preys
Two mothers, decades of friendship, and children who are wrecking both families.
Tyler Perry wrote and directed this one without Madea. Kathy Bates plays a wealthy matriarch and Alfre Woodard her working-class best friend, and the drama is what their grown children do to each other: affairs, business betrayals and one long-buried secret. Sanaa Lathan and Taraji P. Henson lead the younger generation.
There is no holiday in it. It earns its place for the friendship at its centre, which is the warmest thing in a film full of people behaving badly.
13Madea's Family Reunion
A wedding, a reunion and a court-ordered teenager, all in Madea's house.
Madea has two nieces in trouble, a runaway she has been made guardian of, and a family reunion to get through. Tyler Perry plays Madea and two other roles, and wrote and directed it. The reason to watch it is the reunion itself, where Cicely Tyson and Maya Angelou sit among the elders.
It is a reunion, not a Thanksgiving dinner, but it is the most crowded table on this list, and it plays best with three generations on the couch.
12This Is Where I Leave You
Four grown siblings, one childhood home, seven days they cannot leave.
After their father dies, the Altman siblings are asked to stay in the family house together for a week. Jason Bateman, Tina Fey and Adam Driver play three of them, with Jane Fonda as their very frank mother. Shawn Levy directed it from Jonathan Tropper's adaptation of his own novel.
No Thanksgiving here either, but it is the most recognisable "everyone is home and nobody can leave" film of the last decade. If you like adaptations, the best movies based on books are collected in their own list.
11Crooklyn
One Brooklyn family, five kids, one summer in 1973.
Spike Lee's semi-autobiographical film follows the Carmichaels of Bedford-Stuyvesant through a summer, told through young Troy (Zelda Harris). Alfre Woodard plays the schoolteacher mother holding it together and Delroy Lindo the jazz-musician father who cannot quite pay the bills.
It is set in summer, which makes it the furthest from Thanksgiving of anything here. It is on the list because few films capture a crowded family house as lovingly, and because its final stretch is among the most moving things Spike Lee has made.
10Soul Food
Forty years of Sunday dinners, and what happens when they stop.
Mother Joe (Irma P. Hall) has held the family together with a dinner every Sunday for decades. When she falls ill the dinners stop, and her three daughters, played by Vanessa Williams, Vivica A. Fox and Nia Long, watch the family start to come apart. Written and directed by George Tillman Jr., with Babyface among its executive producers.
It is the closest a non-Thanksgiving film gets: the whole story is about what a family meal holds together. It is the one to watch the week before, to put you in the mood to cook.
The Thanksgiving movies
Every film from here on takes place at Thanksgiving: getting there, cooking it, or sitting through it.
9Free Birds
Two turkeys, one time machine, and a plan to get turkey off the menu.
A pardoned turkey (Owen Wilson) and a militant one (Woody Harrelson) steal a government time machine voiced by George Takei and fly back to the first Thanksgiving to change what goes on the table. Amy Poehler voices the turkey they meet there.
It is rated PG and it is the only animated feature here, which makes it the easy pick when the kids' table outnumbers the adults. Adults will find it slight; children find the premise hilarious.
8Dutch
A road trip home for Thanksgiving with a kid who does not want to go.
To win over his girlfriend's son, a working-class guy (Ed O'Neill) volunteers to drive the boy (Ethan Embry) home to Chicago from his Southern prep school for Thanksgiving. The boy is a snob, the car does not survive, and neither do their wallets.
Critics were not kind when it came out, and it was a box-office failure (outside the US it was retitled Driving Me Crazy). It has since found a following as a Thanksgiving comfort watch, and it makes an ideal double bill with number one, the film critics accused it of copying.
7Friendsgiving
No family, all chaos: the Thanksgiving you host for your friends.
A newly divorced actress (Malin Akerman), her newly single best friend (Kat Dennings) and her mother (Jane Seymour) host a dinner for a table of friends and near-strangers that goes off the rails course by course. Wanda Sykes, Chelsea Peretti and Aisha Tyler are among the guests. Nicol Paone wrote and directed it.
It is rated R and it is the most modern film here: the holiday as the dinner you throw when going home is not an option. Save it for the night before, after the kids are asleep.
6What's Cooking?
Four Los Angeles families, four Thanksgiving dinners, one long day.
Gurinder Chadha, two years before Bend It Like Beckham, cuts between four families of different backgrounds cooking the same holiday. Alfre Woodard, Mercedes Ruehl, Kyra Sedgwick and Joan Chen lead the four households, and the film keeps cutting from kitchen to kitchen until the dinners collide with what each family has been avoiding.
It is the most underseen film on this list and the most purely about the meal itself. Look out for Alfre Woodard: she is in three of the fifteen films on this list.
5Pieces of April
One estranged daughter, one broken oven, one dinner she has to get right.
April (Katie Holmes) invites the family she has drifted from to her small New York apartment for Thanksgiving, because her mother (Patricia Clarkson) is seriously ill. Then her oven will not work, and she has to knock on her neighbours' doors to get the turkey cooked while her family drives toward the city.
It runs 81 minutes, the shortest feature here. Peter Hedges wrote and directed it, and Clarkson was nominated for the Oscar for Best Supporting Actress. It is funny right up until it is not, and the ending earns every tear.
4Home for the Holidays
Lost her job, kissed her boss, and now she has to go home.
Jodie Foster directed it, and it is the most accurate film ever made about the specific exhaustion of going home as an adult. Its Thanksgiving dinner, where the family finally says out loud what it has been thinking for years, is as painful as it is funny.
3Hannah and Her Sisters
Three sisters, their men and their mistakes, told between Thanksgiving dinners.
Hannah (Mia Farrow) hosts the family every Thanksgiving, and the film uses those dinners as its frame while her husband (Michael Caine) falls for her sister Lee (Barbara Hershey) and her other sister Holly (Dianne Wiest) stumbles from one career to the next.
It won three Oscars: Caine and Wiest for their supporting performances, and Woody Allen for the original screenplay. It is the most adult film here, and it is the one where Thanksgiving is less a setting than a clock: every dinner shows you how much has changed since the last.
2A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving
Toast, popcorn, pretzel sticks and jelly beans. Good grief.
Peppermint Patty invites herself and her friends to Charlie Brown's for Thanksgiving, and Charlie Brown, who can make cereal and toast, has to feed them. Linus, Snoopy and Woodstock step in, and the result is the most famous meal in holiday television. Directed by Bill Melendez and Phil Roman, it first aired in November 1973.
It runs 25 minutes and is rated G, so it fits before dinner, between courses, or while the turkey rests. Looking for its October counterpart? The best Halloween movies for kids are ranked by how scary each one is.
1Planes, Trains and Automobiles
Two men and every possible way to not get home for Thanksgiving.
Neal Page (Steve Martin), an uptight marketing executive, is trying to get home to Chicago for Thanksgiving. Every flight, train and rental car fails him, and the only constant is Del Griffith (John Candy), a cheerful, relentless shower-curtain-ring salesman who will not stop talking.
John Hughes wrote and directed it, and it opened the week of Thanksgiving 1987. It is rated R, almost entirely for one rental-counter tirade, and that scene is the funniest thing on this list. The ending is the most moving. It is number one because it is the only film here that is about the whole holiday at once: the travel, the people you are stuck with, and why you go home at all.